A homegrown movement to protect the pure waters & famed rivers of Southwest Oregon's Kalmiopsis - Wild Rivers Coast Region

Local support for a 20-year Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal overwhelms a third time

Neither the dark of night nor the rains of November deterred opponents of nickel strip mining in the Kalmiopsis and Wild Rivers Coast regions from making their voices heard at the recent public hearing in Brookings, Oregon. Residents of the communities that would be most affected by the development of industrial-scale mines turned out in record numbers to support the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) and Bureau of Land Management’s (BLM) proposed 20-year Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal

testifying for mineral withdrawal to packed crowd
U. S. Forest Service and BLM officials and congressional staff for Senator Ron Wyden, Senator Jeff Merkley, Congressman Peter DeFazio and Congressman Jared Huffman listen to testimony in support of the 20-year Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal.

It was the third hearing and fifth opportunity for public comment in the administrative proposal to temporarily close 101,000 acres of river-rich National Forest and BLM lands in Southwest Oregon to mining. The purpose of the mineral withdrawal is to prevent harm to these exceptional public lands while their permanent protection is under consideration by congress. As before, public support for the measure was overwhelming.

Withdrawal supporters show off photos or rare wildflowers
Supporters of the Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal show off some of the rare wildflowers that are found in the headwaters of Hunter Creek and the proposed Veva Stansell Botanical Area in the withdrawal area.

Speakers left no doubt that protecting the area’s clean drinking water, native salmon and steelhead runs and National Wild and Scenic Rivers from metal mining—the most polluting industry in the nation—was an absolute priority.  

Of the approximately 45,000 comments received by the BLM and USFS earlier, 99.9% supported the Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal. Most argued that the high conservation values of these public lands called for the maximum possible protection—a withdrawal of 20 years.

The third Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal hearing in Brookings, Oregon demonstrated overwhelming local support of the measure to protect clean drinking water and wild rivers from nickel strip mines.
The third Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal hearing in Brookings, Oregon demonstrated overwhelming local support of the measure to protect clean drinking water and wild rivers from nickel strip mines.

This resulted in the USFS and BLM’s amendment to the original 5-year withdrawal proposal. The agencies have now applied to withdraw the area for 20-years requiring the third public hearing, plus another opportunity for the public to submit written remarks.

So despite the cold, rain and narrow winding roads, over 350 people came from as far way as Port Orford in the north, Crescent City in the south, and inland from Grants Pass and the Illinois River Valley to speak out for protecting their clean drinking water and beautiful rivers and creeks from the industrial pollution of big mining. 

Since it was a school night and a long drive to Brookings, student at the Dome Schools in the Illinois Valley sent their own representatives and a strong (and beautiful) message of support for the 20-year Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal.
Students of the Dome Schools, in the Illinois Valley, sent their own representatives and a strong and beautiful message of support for the 20-year Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal.

The 20-year Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal is supported by the Gold Beach, Crescent City and Cave Junction city councils, plus the water districts for Gasquet, Hiouchi and the Redwoods State and National Parks. It also has the support of the Del Norte Board of Supervisors with good reason. The majority of Del Norte County residents get their drinking water—some of the cleanest in the nation—from the National Wild and Scenic Smith River downstream from where a foreign-owned mining company is trying to develop a nickel strip mine, known as the Cleopatra Project

Photos of beautiful rivers
Supporters of the Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal couldn’t bring the creeks and rivers to the hearing, so they brought the next best thing to show what would be at risk from the development of nickel strip mines.

Residents of the Illinois River Valley made the long trip to Brookings, because since the 1990s they’ve been working to protect the Rough and Ready Creek area from nickel mining and the largest known attempt to privatize public lands under the 1872 Mining Law. In 2011, the threat of mining resurfaced at Rough and Ready Creek as the RNR Project

Supporters of the proposed withdrawal brought photos of the beautiful creeks and rivers
Supporters of the proposed Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal brought photos of the pristine streams and rivers that would be protected from nickel strip mines.

The third area under threat is the headwaters of Hunter Creek and the North Fork Pistol River where the proposed Red Flat Project is located, just 10 miles inland from Cape Sebastian State Park and a little southeast of Gold Beach. The Red Flat Project is the 2nd of two nickel mine development proposals by the foreign-owned Red Flat Nickel Corporation. It’s been strongly opposed by Gold Beach and the small communities of private property owners along both streams.

The diversity of the citizens that have come together to oppose the mining and protect the clean drinking water and wild salmon of this unique rugged corner of Oregon and California is only rivaled by that of the land itself. The tie binding these far flung communities is the abundance of beautiful creeks and rivers that flow from the rugged, wild watersheds of the Kalmiopsis and Coast ranges and the need to protect the priceless resource of clean water and the wild salmon.

crowd at Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal hearing
Despite the dark and rain of November 15th, supporters of the U.S. Forest Service and BLM’s proposed Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal turned out in record numbers for a third public hearing.

Senators Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley and Representatives Peter DeFazio and Jared Huffman are working hard to make the withdrawal permanent. On Feb. 3, 2015, they introduced the Southwestern Oregon Watershed and Salmon Projection Act (H.R. 682 and S. 346). Representative Earl Blumenauer has joined his colleagues.

The bill would not only make the 101,000-acre proposed Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal permanent but it would also permanently protect from mining 17 miles of the National Wild and Scenic Chetco River, where the municipality of Brookings, Oregon gets its drinking water.

hearings panel
The panel hearing public testimony included representatives of the BLM, Rogue River-Siskiyou National Forest, Medford and Coos Bay BLM Districts and the offices of Senator Wyden, Senator Merkley and Representatives Peter DeFazio and Jared Huffman.

Representatives from each of the congressional offices have attended all three hearings to listen to the views of the public. At Brookings they read strong statements of support for the U.S. Forest Service and BLM’s proposal for a 20-year and for protecting the area’s clean, clear drinking water and beautiful rivers. 

After public input from the 5th comment period is in, the Director of the BLM will make a recommendation to the Secretary of Interior on whether to withdraw the National Forest and BLM lands and for how long, The Secretary makes the ultimate decision.

Three hundred fifty filled the Brookings High School Auditorium. When a representative of the Northwest Steelheaders asked the crowed to raise their hands if the supported the 20-year withdrawal the vast majority of the crowd raised their hands.
350 people filled the Brookings, Oregon High School Auditorium. When a representative of the Northwest Steelheaders asked the crowed to raise their hands if they supported the 20-year mineral withdrawal the vast majority of the crowd raised their hands.

More information about the Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal

  • Learn about the proposed Southwest Oregon Mineral Withdrawal and support for it here, and
  • About the proposed amendment to the withdrawal to make it for 20-years here.
  • Learn about the Southwest Oregon Watershed and Salmon Projection Act here,
  • Click here for more about the Rough and Ready Creek and North Fork Smith River (including Baldface Creek) Proposed Withdrawal Area.
  • And here to learn about the Hunter Creek and North Fork Pistol River Headwaters Withdrawal Area.
  • This page explains mineral withdrawals in general
  • Media and video.
crowd at Southwest Oregon Mineral Withrawal
While 95 of the 350 attending the hearing signed up to testify, there was time  only 57 to speak. There were only about 3 who testified in opposition to the withdrawal.

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.